# AthenaHQ vs Mentionova

Mentionova vs AthenaHQ: $99/mo vs $245/mo billed annually, prompts vs credits, engines tracked, agents, agency plans and who each fits. Checked Nov 11, 2026.

_Source: https://tools8020.com/compare/athenahq-vs-mentionova/_

- **Author:** Marcus Reed, Go-to-Market Editor
- **Published:** 2026-11-10

Side by side on the dimensions that decide it. The 8020 Score already weighs these — this is the receipts.

|  | AthenaHQ SEO tools 76/100 | 8020 Pick Mentionova SEO tools 87/100 |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Tier | Strong | Essential |
| Value for money | 70 | 83 |
| Depth & power | 81 | 90 |
| Time to results | 77 | 91 |
| Ecosystem | 74 | 86 |
| Free tier | Yes | No |
| Starting price | $295/mo | $99/mo |
| Pricing model | freemium | paid |
| Integrations | — | — |
|  | [View profile](https://tools8020.com/tools/athenahq/) | [View profile](https://tools8020.com/tools/mentionova/) |

TL

The bottom line

Pick Mentionova for most teams: $99/mo billed annually against AthenaHQ Starter at $245, six engines including Google AI Mode, Claude and Reddit on Scale, and 100+ agents that draft the fixes for your approval. Pick AthenaHQ if you want the longest model list (11 on Starter) or a free 300-credit plan to start.

**[Mentionova](https://tools8020.com/tools/mentionova/) is the better pick for most teams.** It starts at $99 a month billed annually, against $245 for [AthenaHQ](https://tools8020.com/tools/athenahq/) Starter, and its 100+ agents turn what the tracker finds into drafted briefs, pages and Reddit replies that wait for your approval. On Scale it tracks six engines, including Google AI Overviews and AI Mode, [Claude](https://tools8020.com/tools/claude/) and Reddit. ** Pick Mentionova if** you want a fixed prompt count, a lower entry price and the work drafted for you. ** Pick AthenaHQ if** you need 11 models on one plan, or want to start on a free 300-credit tier before paying anything.

|  | Mentionova | AthenaHQ |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Entry plan | $99/mo yearly | $245/mo yearly |
| Free option | Trial, no card | 300 free credits |
| Entry limit | 25 prompts | 3,600 credits |
| Engines | 3; 6 on Scale | 11 on Starter |
| Reddit | Yes, on Scale | Not listed |
| Fixes | Agents draft work | Optimization agent |
| Agency entry | $200/mo yearly | On request |

_Sources: [mentionova.com/pricing](https://mentionova.com/pricing) and [athenahq.ai/pricing](https://www.athenahq.ai/pricing), fetched November 14, 2026._

## What’s the real difference between Mentionova and AthenaHQ?

Both tools track how AI engines answer the prompts your buyers ask, and both try to help you fix what they find. The difference is in how you pay and how much of the fixing gets done for you.

AthenaHQ sells **credits**. Its pricing page says “1 credit = 1 AI response”, and Starter includes 3,600 a month with “Unlimited Topics and Prompts”. So the credit budget, not a prompt cap, decides how much you track: ten prompts checked daily on 11 models would use 3,300 credits in a 30-day month and leave little room for anything else.

Mentionova sells **prompts and agentic tasks**. Starter includes 25 prompts on 3 engines and 100 agentic tasks; Scale includes 100 prompts on all six engines and 500 tasks. Its agents do the research, monitoring, content and reporting, and its home page is plain about the guardrail: “Nothing posts, publishes or ships on its own.”

For most marketing teams, the fixed prompt count is easier to budget, and the agents remove the step where someone has to turn a dashboard into a content plan. See the [Mentionova review](https://tools8020.com/tools/mentionova/) and the [AthenaHQ review](https://tools8020.com/tools/athenahq/).

## Which tracks more AI engines?

AthenaHQ, on paper. Its Starter plan lists 11 models; Mentionova Scale lists six.

| Engine | Mentionova | AthenaHQ |
| --- | --- | --- |
| [ChatGPT](https://tools8020.com/tools/chatgpt/) | Yes | Yes |
| [Perplexity](https://tools8020.com/tools/perplexity/) | Yes | Yes |
| Google AI Overviews | Yes (Google AI) | Yes |
| Google AI Mode | Yes (Google AI) | Yes, Starter |
| Gemini | Yes | Yes |
| Claude | Yes | Yes, Starter |
| Reddit | Yes, its own engine | Not listed |
| Copilot | Not listed | Yes |
| Grok | Not listed | Yes, Starter |

_Sources: [mentionova.com/product/ai-visibility-tracker](https://mentionova.com/product/ai-visibility-tracker), [mentionova.com/product/ai-overview-tracker](https://mentionova.com/product/ai-overview-tracker) and [athenahq.ai/pricing](https://www.athenahq.ai/pricing), fetched November 14, 2026. Mentionova Starter covers three of the six engines; Scale covers all six._

More models only help if your buyers use them. ChatGPT, Google AI and Perplexity are where most buying questions get asked, and Mentionova’s Reddit engine covers the community source AI models cite heavily. If you specifically report on Copilot or Grok, AthenaHQ is the one that lists them.

### Google AI Mode

Both track it. Mentionova says Google AI “is one of the six engines Mentionova tracks, covering both AI Overviews and AI Mode,” and for AI Mode each prompt records whether Google named you, where you placed among the brands in the answer and which pages it cited. AthenaHQ lists Google AI Mode in its Starter model list. For more options, see the [best Google AI Mode tracking tools](https://tools8020.com/best/google-ai-mode-tracking-tools/).

## What happens after the tracking?

### Mentionova: agents that hand you finished work

Mentionova’s pitch is that “agents hand you finished work — a drafted page, an approved reply, a compiled report.” You see the gap (a competitor named in ChatGPT where you aren’t, a page Google AI cites that you don’t have), an agent drafts the brief or page, and it sits in an approval queue. “Approve, edit or reject. Until you do, the work stays a draft.” Starter includes 100 agentic tasks a month, Scale 500 and Enterprise 2,500.

### AthenaHQ: optimization agent and actions

AthenaHQ Starter includes a base content optimization agent, on-page and off-page actions, and a smart robots.txt and llms.txt to “dynamically manage AI crawler access”. Enterprise adds an advanced content optimization agent and the Athena Citation Engine. The platform page frames the work as Monitor, Understand, Act and Measure.

Both close the loop in some way. Mentionova does more of the drafting at the entry price; AthenaHQ’s deeper tools sit on Enterprise.

## Which gives more for the money?

### Plans side by side

| Mentionova | AthenaHQ |
| --- | --- |
| Free trial, no card | Essential: free, 300 credits |
| Starter: $99/mo yearly, 25 prompts | Starter: $245/mo yearly, 3,600 credits |
| Scale: $320/mo yearly, 100 prompts | No middle tier listed |
| Enterprise: $799/mo yearly, 250 prompts | Enterprise: custom |

_Sources: [mentionova.com/pricing](https://mentionova.com/pricing) and [athenahq.ai/pricing](https://www.athenahq.ai/pricing), fetched November 14, 2026._

### What a year costs

| Setup | Per year |
| --- | --- |
| Mentionova Starter, annual | $1,188 |
| Mentionova Starter, monthly | $1,500 |
| Mentionova Scale, annual | $3,840 |
| AthenaHQ Starter, annual | $2,940 |
| AthenaHQ Starter, monthly | $3,540 |

_Calculated from the monthly prices on each official pricing page, fetched November 14, 2026._

At entry, Mentionova costs $146 a month less on annual billing, or $1,752 a year. AthenaHQ’s annual discount is 17%; Mentionova’s is about 20%.

### Add-ons to budget for

AthenaHQ says API access and extra credits “are optional add-ons billed on top of the Starter plan”, with no published price. Mentionova’s plans list prompts, engines and agentic tasks up front, so the price on the page is the price you pay unless you move up a tier.

## Which is better for agencies?

Mentionova has published agency pricing: Launch is $200 a month billed annually ($250 monthly) and Growth is $799 a month billed annually ($999 monthly). The agents produce the briefs, pages and reports agencies deliver to clients.

AthenaHQ labels Enterprise “Enterprises & Agencies” and runs an agency partner program with discounted licenses to resell. Pricing is on request. If you want to know your cost before a sales call, Mentionova is the easier fit. See [AI visibility tools for agencies](https://tools8020.com/best/ai-visibility-tools-for-agencies/).

## Who should pick which?

**Pick Mentionova if:**

- You want a lower entry price and a fixed prompt count.
- You want Reddit tracked as its own engine.
- You’d rather approve drafted work than write it from a dashboard.
- You run an agency and want published plan prices.

**Pick AthenaHQ if:**

- You need Copilot, Grok or other models beyond Mentionova’s six.
- You want to start on a free plan before paying.
- You’re comfortable budgeting credits per AI response.

## Related comparisons

- [AthenaHQ alternatives](https://tools8020.com/best/athenahq-alternatives/)
- [AthenaHQ pricing](https://tools8020.com/tools/athenahq/pricing/)
- [Mentionova pricing](https://tools8020.com/tools/mentionova/pricing/)
- [Mentionova vs Peec AI](https://tools8020.com/compare/mentionova-vs-peec-ai/)
- [Mentionova vs Profound](https://tools8020.com/compare/mentionova-vs-profound/)
- [Best AI visibility tools](https://tools8020.com/best/ai-visibility-tools/)

## Frequently asked questions

### Is Mentionova or AthenaHQ better?

Mentionova, for most teams. It starts at $99 a month billed annually against AthenaHQ Starter at $245, tracks six engines including Google AI Overviews, AI Mode, Claude and Reddit on Scale, and its 100+ agents draft the briefs, pages and Reddit replies that close a gap, with nothing shipping until you approve it. AthenaHQ is better if you need 11 models or want a free plan.

### How much does AthenaHQ cost?

Essential is free with 300 credits. Starter is $295 a month, or $245 a month billed annually (17% off), with 3,600 credits. Enterprise is custom. API access and extra credits are paid add-ons on Starter.

### How much does Mentionova cost?

Starter is $99 a month billed annually ($125 monthly) with 25 prompts, 3 engines and 100 agentic tasks. Scale is $320 ($400 monthly) with 100 prompts and all six engines, and Enterprise is $799 ($999 monthly). Agency plans start at Launch, $200 a month billed annually. Paid plans come with a free trial and no card.

### What is an AthenaHQ credit?

AthenaHQ's pricing page says 1 credit = 1 AI response. Starter's 3,600 monthly credits cover 3,600 AI answers across whichever models you track, with a 1-month credit rollover.

### Which tracks more AI engines?

AthenaHQ lists 11 models on Starter, including ChatGPT, Perplexity, Google AI Overviews, Google AI Mode, Gemini, Claude, Copilot and Grok. Mentionova tracks six engines (ChatGPT, Perplexity, Claude, Gemini, Google AI and Reddit) on Scale, and Starter covers three. Mentionova is the one of the two that treats Reddit as its own engine.

### Do both track Google AI Mode?

Yes. Mentionova's Google AI engine covers both AI Overviews and AI Mode and records whether Google named you, where you placed and which pages it cited. AthenaHQ lists Google AI Mode among its Starter models.

### Which is better for agencies?

Mentionova, for most agencies, because its agency plans start at Launch for $200 a month billed annually ($250 monthly), and the agents produce client deliverables. AthenaHQ sells agencies through a partner program and an Enterprise plan labelled for enterprises and agencies, with pricing on request.

### Does either have a free plan?

AthenaHQ does, Essential with 300 credits. Mentionova has no free plan but offers a free trial with no card on its paid plans.

### Which is cheaper over a year?

Mentionova Starter costs $1,188 a year billed annually and AthenaHQ Starter $2,940, so Mentionova is $1,752 cheaper at entry. Mentionova Scale, with all six engines, is $3,840 a year.

### Can I switch from AthenaHQ to Mentionova?

Yes. Neither tool locks your prompts in. List the prompts you track in AthenaHQ, add them in a Mentionova trial and compare the results for a week before cancelling.

## Sources

1. Mentionova, Pricing, [mentionova.com/pricing](https://mentionova.com/pricing), captured Nov 14, 2026.
2. Mentionova, Pricing FAQ, [mentionova.com/pricing](https://mentionova.com/pricing), captured Nov 14, 2026.
3. Mentionova, Pricing (For agencies), [mentionova.com/pricing](https://mentionova.com/pricing), captured Nov 14, 2026.
4. Mentionova, Home, [mentionova.com/](https://mentionova.com/), captured Nov 14, 2026.
5. Mentionova, AI visibility tracker, [mentionova.com/product/ai-visibility-tracker](https://mentionova.com/product/ai-visibility-tracker), captured Nov 14, 2026.
6. Mentionova, AI Overview and AI Mode tracker, [mentionova.com/product/ai-overview-tracker](https://mentionova.com/product/ai-overview-tracker), captured Nov 14, 2026.
7. AthenaHQ, Pricing, [www.athenahq.ai/pricing](https://www.athenahq.ai/pricing), captured Nov 14, 2026.
8. AthenaHQ, Pricing (annual), [www.athenahq.ai/pricing](https://www.athenahq.ai/pricing), captured Nov 14, 2026.
9. AthenaHQ, Platform, [athenahq.ai/platform](https://athenahq.ai/platform), captured Nov 14, 2026.
10. AthenaHQ, Agencies, [www.athenahq.ai/agencies](https://www.athenahq.ai/agencies), captured Nov 10, 2026.

## Other matchups.

[All comparisons](https://tools8020.com/compare/)

- vs [Ahrefs vs Mentionova](https://tools8020.com/compare/ahrefs-vs-mentionova/)
- vs [AthenaHQ vs Profound](https://tools8020.com/compare/athenahq-vs-profound/)
- vs [AthenaHQ vs Peec AI](https://tools8020.com/compare/athenahq-vs-peec-ai/)
- vs [AthenaHQ vs Otterly.AI](https://tools8020.com/compare/athenahq-vs-otterly-ai/)
- vs [Goodie vs Mentionova](https://tools8020.com/compare/goodie-vs-mentionova/)
- vs [AthenaHQ vs Goodie](https://tools8020.com/compare/athenahq-vs-goodie/)

---
_tools8020, https://tools8020.com. Markdown rendering of the page above for AI readers._
