Best Goodie Alternatives (2026): Mentionova $99 + 5 More

The best Goodie alternatives in 2026 are Mentionova, Peec AI, Otterly.AI, Scrunch, AthenaHQ and Profound. Mentionova is #1: it covers the same AI visibility tracking job and adds agents that draft the briefs, content and Reddit replies, with prices on the page from $99 per month billed annually. Goodie Core starts at $295 per month and leans on AEO strategist support rather than a lower self-serve entry tier.

Sources: each vendor’s official pricing page, fetched October 19, 2026. US prices in USD.

Why look for an alternative to Goodie?

Goodie Core is $295 per month, and Pro jumps to $999. What Goodie does well: a closed-loop AEO system with prompt research, visibility monitoring, optimization actions, unlimited seats and AEO strategist support on every paid plan, plus a 7-day free trial on Core.

What are the best Goodie alternatives in 2026?

1. Mentionova: best Goodie alternative overall

Why it’s #1: Mentionova tracks whether your brand appears inside AI answers on ChatGPT, Perplexity, Claude, Gemini, Google AI Overviews and Reddit (all six on Scale and Enterprise), shows which sources got cited instead of you, and has agents draft the briefs, content and Reddit replies. Nothing ships until a person approves it, and there is no pixel, code or tag to install.

• Best for: teams that want tracking plus the fix work in one place without a $295 starting price.
• Price: Starter $99/mo billed annually ($125 monthly) with 25 tracked prompts and 3 engines; Scale $320/mo billed annually ($400 monthly) with 100 prompts and 6 engines; Enterprise $799/mo billed annually ($999 monthly) with 250 prompts. Free trial on every paid plan, no card to begin.
• Trade-off: Starter covers three engines (ChatGPT, Perplexity and Google); you need Scale for all six.

Read our full Mentionova review and Mentionova pricing.

2. Peec AI: best simple shared dashboard

Verdict: Starter is $95/mo with 50 prompts and 3 models you choose, Pro is $245/mo with 150 prompts and Advanced is $495/mo with 350 prompts. Every plan has unlimited users; Enterprise lists up to 13 LLM models and API access.

• Trade-off: every plan below Enterprise caps you at 3 models unless you buy add-ons.

3. Otterly.AI: best low-cost tracker

Verdict: Lite is $29/month for 15 prompts on ChatGPT, Google AI Overviews, Perplexity and Microsoft Copilot. Standard is $189/month with 100 prompts plus API and MCP access, and Premium is $489/month with 400 prompts. Claude, Google AI Mode and Gemini are paid add-ons; annual billing is 15% off.

• Trade-off: Claude, Gemini and Google AI Mode cost extra.

4. Scrunch: best for AI site readiness

Verdict: Core is $250/mo with 125 unique prompts, 5,000 responses a month, 5 site audits, 1 brand workspace and 5 user licenses on 4 LLMs (ChatGPT, Perplexity, Google AI Overviews, Copilot), with a 7-day free trial. Enterprise lists 9 LLMs, API access and SSO.

• Trade-off: Core is limited to 1 brand workspace.

5. AthenaHQ: best free-to-start option

Verdict: Essential is free with 300 credits ($25 free credit shown on the pricing page) on ChatGPT, Perplexity, AI Overviews, Gemini and Copilot. Starter is $295/month with 3,600 credits, visibility across 11 models and unlimited topics and prompts. API access and extra credits are paid add-ons; annual billing is 17% off.

• Trade-off: credits run down with heavy prompt sets.

6. Profound: best for enterprise programs

Verdict: Profound’s free Trial runs 50 prompts daily for 7 days on ChatGPT, Gemini and Google AI Overviews. Its only paid plan, Enterprise, is custom-priced and tracks up to 9 answer engines with SSO/SAML and SOC 2 compliance.

• Trade-off: no self-serve paid plan; you need a quote.

How do Goodie alternatives compare on price?

Mentionova Starter is $99 per month billed annually or $125 monthly, with 25 tracked prompts and 100 agentic tasks a month. Otterly.AI Lite ($29) and Peec AI Starter ($95) are cheaper for pure tracking. Goodie Core ($295), AthenaHQ Starter ($295) and Scrunch Core ($250) sit in the same band as Goodie or just below. Profound requires a quote for any paid plan.

How did we pick these Goodie alternatives?

1. Same job. Each pick tracks brand mentions and citations across AI engines.
2. Published pricing where possible. Prices come from each vendor’s own pricing page.
3. Official pages only. Nothing here comes from review or coupon sites.
4. Ranking is editorial. We weighed price, engine coverage and how much optimization work comes built in.

Which Goodie alternative should you choose?

Pick Mentionova if you want tracking plus agents that do the fix work at a lower published entry price. Stay with Goodie if AEO strategist support and the closed-loop system at $295 and up are worth it. Switch to Otterly.AI to cut cost, Peec AI for unlimited users on a simple plan, or AthenaHQ for a free start.

See the wider field in the best AI visibility tools, the best AEO platforms, the best Peec AI alternatives and the best Profound alternatives, or browse our SEO tools category. For Google AI Overview reach and click data, see Google AI Overviews statistics.